Should I Rent or Buy a Home | Team Coyle @ Compass

Not Sure Whether to Rent or Buy? | Read This First

With mortgage rates rising, many prospective homebuyers are wondering if they should rent or buy a home. 

To answer this question, I turned to NerdWallet’s rent vs. buy calculator to compare the costs/benefits of either option using the following key assumptions:

Rent or buy

For other assumptions like property taxes (1.02% per annum), rent and home appreciation rates (5% per annum), insurance, etc. I used NerdWallet’s default settings.  Like any model, the accuracy of the estimate will largely depend on the quality of the assumptions used which could materially differ from actual results.     

The NerdWallet calculator, however, suggests that the approximate breakeven point between whether it is better to buy or rent a home is approximately six years (see Chart following).  In other words, if you are planning to live in the condo for six or more years, then buying is the more cost effective/economical option.  Conversely, if you are planning to live in the condo for less than six years, then renting is probably the better option all else equal.

rent or buy home | nerdwallet

Nanxi He is a real estate agent and a member of Team Coyle @ Compass.

About TEAM COYLE

Team Coyle,  a professional group of real estate agents at Compass, has more than ten years of experience helping individuals and families buy and sell real estate in the Greater Boston Region of Massachusetts (primarily MetroWest).

Matt & Ying Coyle, Team Coyle — Compass agents in Wellesley

Get your free home valuation now

Serving Wellesley and other Greater Boston towns
Scroll to Top

Get in Touch

Matt Coyle, REALTOR®
Address
161 Linden St, Suite 102
Wellesley, MA 02482

Methodology

TownRatings™ is a proprietary model developed by Team Coyle to provide homebuyers and sellers with a relative rating (assessment) of a town’s key characteristics, benchmarked against other Greater Boston towns. Ratings are based on publicly available data and Team Coyle’s on-the-ground expertise and are intended as a general guide only. Please consult a licensed real estate professional before making any real estate decisions. Ratings are current as of October 4, 2025.

RATING CATEGORIES

  • Quality of Schools: Based on Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) 2024 data, emphasizing Grade 10 MCAS English Language Arts and Mathematics proficiency rates and 4-year high school graduation rates. Together, these measures provide a snapshot of academic achievement and long-term outcomes.
    Scale: Above Average · Average · Below Average
  • Commute to Boston: Assesses commuting ease using travel time, distance, and in-town transit access. For towns with MBTA rail or subway service, commute times are measured to the line’s natural Boston endpoint (e.g., North Station, South Station, or Back Bay). For towns without in-town service, commute times are measured by car to Back Bay as the default reference point.
    Scale: Easy · Moderate · Challenging
  • Shopping & Dining: Reflects the density and variety of retail and restaurant options within a town or in adjacent hubs.
    Scale: Excellent · Good · Limited
  • Lifestyle: A general description a town's overall character (e.g., Upscale, Rural, Historic, Suburban, Urban/Vibrant).
  • Est. Annual Tax per $1M: The town’s residential property tax rate applied to $1,000,000 of value (as of the report date) for easy comparison.

HOW RATINGS ARE DERIVED

Ratings are determined using a blend of publicly reported data (e.g., DESE reports, MBTA schedules, municipal tax rates, business directories), mapping and transportation tools, and qualitative insights from Team Coyle agents active in these markets.

LIMITATIONS & DISCLAIMERS

  • Informational only; subject to change without notice.
  • No duty to update: Team Coyle and its agents are not obligated to refresh or revise ratings.
  • No warranties: Information is provided “as is” without warranties of any kind.
  • No liability: Team Coyle, its agents, and Compass are not liable for any losses, damages, or costs arising from use or reliance.
  • Not advice: not legal, tax, financial, educational, or transportation advice. Consult a licensed real estate professional/agent and other appropriate professionals.
  • Verify independently: Commute times vary (route/time/weather) — check MBTA schedules and test commutes. School offerings and performance change — confirm with districts and the MA Dept. of Elementary & Secondary Education. Amenities evolve — verify locally.
  • Third-party content not endorsed; accuracy not guaranteed. Trademarks belong to their owners.
  • Broker disclosure: Compass is a licensed real estate broker and abides by Equal Housing Opportunity laws.
  • Fair housing: Nothing here should be used to encourage or discourage housing decisions based on protected characteristics.